Connect with others who understand.

  • Learn from expert-reviewed resources
  • Real advice from people who’ve been there
  • People who understand what you’re going through
Sign Up Log In
Powered By
Real members of MyBCTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.
A MyBCTeam Member asked a question 💭
Panama City Beach, FL

Hi everyone,
I was just diagnosed with Stage 1 DCIS and am having to decide between a lumpectomy w/ radiation and a mastectomy.

For those that have had a lumpectomy w/ radiation would you choose this again if you had to do it over again... or would you choose a mastectomy? unilateral or bilateral?

Thank you for your insight in advance?

May 23, 2014 (edited)
 · 
Reactions
A MyBCTeam Member

My BC was more advanced - ended up being Stage III - but I chose lumpectomy. My surgeon emphasized that as long as I had radiation in addition, the outcomes were similar. Some studies have actually said recurrence is a little less with lumpectomy+radiation than with mastectomy. With sentinel node biopsy, cancer cells were found in 5 lymph, so radiation would have been a no-brainer anyway. It has been almost 10 years since my diagnosis, with no recurrence or metastases, so I feel very good about my choice. And if you choose lumpectomy first, you can always go to mastectomy later - you can't do it the other way!

May 24, 2014
A MyBCTeam Member

I had lumpectomy because stage 1 and small tumor,however everyone else was having masectomys so I thought I made the wrong decision. My oncologist said I made the right decision! Had my first scan two days ago and still clear! I am taking letrozole side effects aren't to bad! Every woman is different! Good luck!

June 12, 2014
A MyBCTeam Member

I had bilateral lumpectomies at the same time because the biopsies were positive. It was invasive stage 1. My Dr said she didn’t see a reason for a mastectomy at this point so I went with her recommendation. I had radiation but didn’t need chemo. It’s been 9 years so I’m glad I followed her advice. The only thing I didn’t follow was taking the pill for 5 years. After 3 months I could not tolerate the side effects. She wanted me to try another pill, but I didn’t want to. It took months before I felt my body and mind returned to normal.

July 23, 2023 (edited)
A MyBCTeam Member

I opted for a lumpectomy with radiation. Surgeon explained to me the chance of reoccurrence was equal to having a mastectomy. I like my boobs and wanted to keep them. It was an easy decision for me. I'm a nurse and have some insight and healthy fear. Didn't want complicated multiple surgeries, prolonged anesthesia, long recovery and big loss of time from work. Surgery is not without it's complications. I was fortunate that I had options. Some don't. Everyone's decision is personal. Do your research, ask questions, pray and don't jump to worse case scenarios. Make a good decision based on information and not fear. Best wishes and hugs!

May 29, 2014
A MyBCTeam Member

I had a lumpectomy & chemo & radiation..I will never do radiation again..I still a year later have issues..every lump or bump freaks me out..I wish I would of done a masectomy but everyone is different I had 33 rounds of radiation my cancer was close to my chest wall by my arm pit so could of been the area is why I had so many problems plus I worked thru my treatments in a kitchen lifting & stuff..I deliver meals to homebound clients so that prob didn't help..I learned a new phrase & I use it often.."My body My Choice" take opinions but in the end its your body your choice..I wish you all the luck in the world..

May 25, 2014

Related Questions

View All
A MyBCTeam Member asked a question 💭
Alpharetta, GA

A MyBCTeam Member asked a question 💭
Rochester, NY

A MyBCTeam Member asked a question 💭
Rochester, NY

Continue with Facebook
Continue with Google
By joining, you accept our Terms of Use, and acknowledge our collection, sharing, and use of your data in accordance with our Health Data and Privacy policies.
Already a member? Log In