Receiving a breast cancer diagnosis can be life-changing for many people, and it’s important to find the right medical team. Seeking a second opinion can help you to confirm your diagnosis, determine the right treatment plan, and gain peace of mind moving forward.
Preparing a short list of questions before your second opinion appointment can help you make the most of your time with a new oncologist. These 10 questions are a strong starting point for clearer answers and more confident, personalized care.
Getting the right breast cancer diagnosis is important because it helps your doctor choose the best treatment plan for you. If you decide to get a second opinion, try to meet with the new doctor soon, ideally before you start treatment. A second opinion is also helpful if you’ve tried treatment, but it hasn’t been successful.
When you meet with a new doctor, ask them to review your test results and confirm your diagnosis. Doctors identify different types of breast cancer based on several factors. The new oncologist may also review your pathology report to confirm the findings or decide whether you need more tests.
Having a second doctor review your test results can be especially helpful if you have a rare type of breast cancer. In a 2018 study of 70 people with breast cancer who sought a second opinion, a team of cancer specialists at a specialized cancer center changed the diagnosis in 43 percent of cases.
Ask your doctor to explain anything you don’t understand, including your biopsy results.
When reviewing your pathology report, the oncologist will also look at biomarkers. These are molecules in the blood or tissues that can be measured. Biomarkers can help doctors understand how the cancer may behave and which treatments may work best. In breast cancer, biomarkers can include hormone receptors and proteins.
Breast cancer cells that contain estrogen or progesterone receptors are classified as hormone receptor-positive (HR-positive). These types of breast cancer tend to be less aggressive in general than hormone receptor-negative (HR-negative) cancers.
Hormone therapies work by lowering hormone levels or blocking the effects of hormones on cancer cells. These treatments can be very effective for HR-positive cancers but don’t work for HR-negative cancers.
The oncologist will also review your HER2 status. HER2 is a protein involved in cell growth and division. Breast cancer cells that contain too many copies of the HER2 gene will make too much HER2 protein. These types of breast cancer, classified as HER2-positive, are more likely to respond to anti-HER2 treatments than HER2-negative cancers.
If a biomarker result isn’t accurate, it could affect how well your treatment works. Ask the doctor to review your results and, if needed, discuss them with a team of specialists.
The stage and grade of your cancer help to determine your prognosis and treatment plan. The stage can range from 0 to 4, depending on the tumor’s size, whether it has spread, its grade, and its hormone receptor and HER2 status. The grade describes how the cancer cells look under a microscope. The higher the grade, the more different the tumor cells look from normal cells.
Higher-grade cancers are generally more likely to grow and spread quickly. A higher stage generally means the cancer is more advanced. Your healthcare team uses your cancer stage and grade to estimate your prognosis and plan your treatment. These factors can also determine which clinical trials you’re eligible for.
After reviewing your test results, the doctor may still have questions. In this case, they may refer you for additional testing.
After an imaging test, such as a mammogram or MRI, a radiologist reviews the images and interprets the results. A new radiologist may interpret the results differently.
Because results from an imaging study can help to determine your treatment plan, it’s essential to be sure that they’re accurate. A 2022 study found that a second review of breast ultrasound images led to changes in care for 12 percent of patients.
Ask the doctor if meeting with a genetic counselor could be helpful. Some breast cancers are linked to inherited gene mutations (changes). Learning whether you have one of these changes may help guide your treatment. It can also give your family useful information about their own cancer risk.
Ask your doctor to review your current treatment plan to make sure it includes the latest treatments supported by medical research for your type of cancer. It’s common for a doctor providing a second opinion to recommend a different treatment plan.
Depending on your type of breast cancer and how advanced it is, there are several treatment options available, including:
When discussing a treatment plan with a new oncologist, ask about the potential benefits, risks, and side effects. This information can help you to understand what to expect and make the right decision for you.
For each treatment option, ask about the potential side effects and long-term risks. Ask questions about how effective the treatment is for your type of breast cancer, and how likely it is that the cancer could come back after treatment.
Each treatment will affect you differently. Systemic treatments like chemotherapy can affect your entire body, while localized treatments like radiation therapy mainly affect the area being treated.
The new doctor may recommend a less aggressive treatment with a lower risk of side effects than the treatment your original doctor recommended. Understanding your tumor’s grade and biomarkers can help your team to identify the most effective treatments with the lowest risks for you.
When meeting with a new doctor, talk about your treatment goals. Depending on how advanced your cancer is, your goal may be a cure. For people with metastatic breast cancer, treatment may focus on controlling the cancer, easing symptoms, and improving quality of life.
Ask your doctor when to start treatment. Your oncologist may recommend starting treatment right away, rather than pursuing more opinions. For example, inflammatory breast cancer is a very aggressive type of cancer.
Because inflammatory breast cancer grows quickly, it’s important to discuss how soon treatment should begin and whether there’s time to get a second opinion without delaying care.
Clinical trials are studies that test new treatments or new ways of using existing treatments, including treatments already approved for breast cancer.
Ask your doctor if they’re aware of any clinical trials that could benefit you. Because breast cancer treatment has improved dramatically in the last few years, there may be new trials starting.
While joining a clinical trial comes with risks and isn’t for everyone, it’s helpful to know if you qualify and what the process would be like.
Learning about all of the treatment options available to you can be overwhelming. Ask your doctor what they’d recommend based on your cancer details, age, overall health, and goals.
Talk with the doctor about your priorities and preferences. You may want the most aggressive treatment possible. Or you may want to prioritize your quality of life as you pursue a less aggressive treatment plan. There isn’t one right answer, so keep an open dialogue with your healthcare team.
After your second opinion appointment, take time to reflect on the conversation. Notice how you felt during the appointment and if you were comfortable with the new provider.
When you’re ready, talk with your original doctor to discuss the new perspective and see if any changes are needed. If they’re open to it, consider asking both doctors to discuss your case to develop a treatment plan.
Remember that there’s no pressure to switch your care if you don’t want to. A second opinion can bring you peace of mind. If the new doctor agrees with your current treatment plan, it may give you the confidence to move forward.
Get updates directly to your inbox.
Become a member to get even more
This is a member-feature!
Sign up for free to view article comments.
We'd love to hear from you! Please share your name and email to post and read comments.
You'll also get the latest articles directly to your inbox.