Connect with others who understand.

sign up log in
About MyBCTeam
Real members of MyBCTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.

How Many Feel Safer Choosing A Mastectomy When A Lumpectomy Is A Viable Option?

How Many Feel Safer Choosing A Mastectomy When A Lumpectomy Is A Viable Option?

A MyBCTeam Member said:

Absolutely! The “survival rates” they spout at you in the beginning are correct...for the first five years. However, the chances of a recurrence are higher with a lumpectomy as more tissue remains. I for one, wanted to be as aggressive as possible from the get go.

posted 2 months ago
A MyBCTeam Member said:

I chose a bilateral mastectomy. I only had Cancer in one, but years of breast issues ( calcium and cysts ) in both of them. I already had 2 lumpectomies and several core biopsies . I just wanted them GONE. No reconstruction, flat and loving it!!!

posted 2 months ago
A MyBCTeam Member said:

It’s a very personal decision. The right decision for one person, even with the same diagnosis, may not be the same for another person. There is no right or wrong choice - just the choice that you decide is right!

Please remember —even a bilateral masectomy does not guarantee that your BC may spread in the future. I’ve heard far too many women say that they chose a bilateral mastectomy so that they never had to worry about a reoccurrence. That is completely not fact based.

My advice, do some research ( but don’t over research) , make your decision, and never second guess your choice. We make those choices based on many things, including our personal emotional situation.

I chose a lumpectomy, had clean margins, found it spread to one lump node, then had chemo, followed by radiation. Five years on AI Letrozole for estrogen + BC , ending after next month. I’m currently a 5 year survivor and doing well. Given what I know now, do I think I should have made different choices- possibly. Yet I am confident that the decision I made was right at the time - no thoughts of “what if I would have?”. Life is too precious to waste it with those thoughts.

Trust yourself. Be well!

posted 2 months ago
A MyBCTeam Member said:

@A MyBCTeam Member: I was dx with one small (1.6cm) tumour and was offered lumpectomy or mastectomy. I went for the mastectomy and it was a damn good call, because I ended up having 3 tumours (one almost 4cm). If I had chosen lumpectomy I would have been required to have a pre-surgery MRI which would have shown the other tumours and taken lumpectomy off the table anyway. But since I chose mastectomy and got an early surgery date there was no time for MRI, and no reason for it because I was removing it all anyway. If I had waited for the MRI it would have delayed my surgery until after the holidays (I was dx Nov 30, had surgery Dec 21) and I was not prepared to wait that long.

It's a personal choice as inthegrey says - I will say I have no regrets doing it the way I did. 💖

posted 2 months ago
A MyBCTeam Member said:

I had my lumpectomy Nov 6 im still recoverying doing well

posted 18 days ago
Browse more questions and answers
Continue with Facebook
Sign up with your email
Already a Member? Log in